Hemingway in Love
I have just read this memoir of a relationship with Ernest Hemingway, written by one of his close friends and confidants.
Many years ago, when I was much younger, I read For Whom the Bell Tolls. I recognised the succinct style which he typifies. I enjoyed the story. I also have come to recognise in the title, and in some of his other titles, the point he was making that we are all involved in some of the world-changing events of our lifetimes, even though they may be taking place a long way away. Other examples would be the dropping of the first atomic bomb, or the events of 9/11.
When he was writing, in 1940, I believe Hemingway was pointing out that the Spanish Civil War was a precursor to the Second World War, a trial run if you like.
And I believe that the Old Man and the Sea, which I read a few years afterwards, also has a kind of "universal hero" aura about it.
I didn't recognise this feature in A Call to Arms. I read this novel about Hemingway's World War I experiences in Italy later still. Perhaps if I re-read it some day I might see it differently, but thinking back I wonder if the events it describes were too close to Hemingway for real comfort, and he had not, understandably, been able to process them so completely.
Finally, many years later, in fact only a couple of months ago, I got round to reading The Sun Also Rises, his first effort. (See my post of 21 November last)
Hemingway in Love is basically about Hemingway's marriages, about his relationships with all four of his wives, though the process of the break-up of his first marriage, and his developing relationship with his second wife, takes up most of the attention of the book. In fact one could say that Hemingway's regret (remorse, guilt?) about his treatment of Hadley, his first wife, was the main theme of the book.
This memoir is an account, presented as verbatim, of Hotchings' chats with Hemingway during the 1950s while he was visiting the older man in France, Cuba or Key West, where he owned a house, or even during a fishing trip reminiscent of the Old Man and the Sea.
The light the book throws on the novels is not great; it mainly relates to The Sun Also Rises, and for my money does not add a great deal to what we learn from that novel itself. Hemingway admits that his friends, depicted in that first novel in thinly disguised form, were incensed that he had paraded them, warts and all, before their crowd of acquaintances in Paris and elsewhere, and most of them hardly spoke to him again! He misjudged the thinness of the disguises he used -- that is what we learn from Hemingway in Love.
Here is a very human writer, who shows us his strengths and his weaknesses as a human being. For that, as a start, his books are worth reading. Try them!
Hemingway in Love is basically about Hemingway's marriages, about his relationships with all four of his wives, though the process of the break-up of his first marriage, and his developing relationship with his second wife, takes up most of the attention of the book. In fact one could say that Hemingway's regret (remorse, guilt?) about his treatment of Hadley, his first wife, was the main theme of the book.
This memoir is an account, presented as verbatim, of Hotchings' chats with Hemingway during the 1950s while he was visiting the older man in France, Cuba or Key West, where he owned a house, or even during a fishing trip reminiscent of the Old Man and the Sea.
The light the book throws on the novels is not great; it mainly relates to The Sun Also Rises, and for my money does not add a great deal to what we learn from that novel itself. Hemingway admits that his friends, depicted in that first novel in thinly disguised form, were incensed that he had paraded them, warts and all, before their crowd of acquaintances in Paris and elsewhere, and most of them hardly spoke to him again! He misjudged the thinness of the disguises he used -- that is what we learn from Hemingway in Love.
Here is a very human writer, who shows us his strengths and his weaknesses as a human being. For that, as a start, his books are worth reading. Try them!